Annualised versus cumulative MPF returns: differences and examples
Cumulative return describes total change over a period. Annualised return expresses an equivalent yearly compound change, not the actual result in every year. Before comparing MPF information, align periods, valuation dates, fund features and calculation methods, and review fees and risk separately.
Book a WhatsApp demoDistinguish fund measures from a personal account result
Read published figures using the source's definitions, including valuation periods, distributions and fee treatment. This article explains measures and does not make a personal investment choice.
| Measure | Question it answers | What it does not establish |
|---|---|---|
| Cumulative return | What was the total change from start to end? | The same return in each year. |
| Annualised return | What yearly compound rate is equivalent to that period's result? | Actual annual results or a future guarantee. |
| Personal account result | What happened with actual contributions, transfers, withdrawals, fees and timing? | A number copied directly from a fund's historical return. |
Match the measurement
| Check | Keep consistent |
|---|---|
| Fund characteristics | Compare similar objectives and asset exposure where meaningful. |
| Time | Use the same as-of date and return period. |
| Return method | Separate annualised, cumulative and calendar-year returns. |
| Fees and risk | State definitions and dates; do not infer them from returns. |
Explain gaps
A fund with a shorter history may have no value for a longer period. Mark the missing observation N/A. A genuine zero reported by the source is different from a value that was not provided.
Document the limit
If the characteristics or dates do not match, show the information separately and explain why a direct comparison would be weak. Keep the source trail so the comparison can be checked later.
A mathematical example: 33.1% over three years is not 33.1% a year
Fictional example: start at 100 and assume a change of +10% in each year. After three years, 100 × 1.1 × 1.1 × 1.1 = 133.1. The cumulative change is 33.1%; the equivalent annualised change is 10%. These are not returns from any real fund.
The conversion is: annualised change = (1 + cumulative change)^(1 ÷ years) − 1. This start-to-end example assumes no intervening contributions, withdrawals or other cash flows, and no additional fees. Do not use it to calculate a personal MPF account return.
| Observation | This fictional example | Can it be used interchangeably? |
|---|---|---|
| Three-year cumulative change | 33.1% | It is not a yearly return. |
| Three-year annualised change | 10% | An equivalent conversion for the same period. |
| Actual yearly changes | Deliberately assumed to be +10% each year here. | Real funds usually vary from year to year. |
Check dates when using official tools
The MPFA's March 2023 article introduces tools for comparing MPF information. It is a starting point, not a current fund return or fee table. For current figures, visit the official platform and record each data set's valuation date separately.
General readers can first identify the fund type and observation period. Advisers preparing meeting material should also retain source URLs, definitions and unmatched items. Keep missing values as N/A rather than zero, and do not create a single performance ranking across different risk categories.
Sources: MPFA — Comparing MPF information · MPFA — MPF Fund Platform
Illustrative method check
Fund A has a five-year annualised figure; Fund B has only a three-year cumulative figure. Request a common period or present them separately. Do not convert either into an invented five-year number.
What to keep in mind
- A comparison is not a ranking of personal suitability. Historical returns do not guarantee future results, and fees or risk data may have a different update date.
Questions, answered
Can I compare every fund category in one table?
You can show information, but do not imply that different objectives and risks form a like-for-like performance contest.
Does N/A mean a fund performed badly?
No. It indicates unavailable or inapplicable information, not poor or zero performance.
Is a five-year annualised 5% better than a three-year cumulative 15%?
Those two numbers alone cannot answer that. The periods differ, and fund features, fees and risk have not been checked. Obtain comparable measures first and explain any remaining limitations.
Sources
- MPFA — MPF Fund Platform Source version date needs checking
- MPFA — Comparing MPF information Source publication month
Check each original document for its date, definitions and scope. A citation does not confirm the latest version or imply endorsement of our examples.
Editorial policy